My book rating system here on The GUNDERSTONE review

I was so interested in getting the site up and running I realized I never actually identified what my star ratings meant here so with that I wanted to release this post.

* * * * * Five Stars – An excellent, compelling, must read, that I could not put down and could see reading again someday.

* * * * Four Stars – A very solid read, one I would recommend to other readers.

* * * Three Stars – A good read; may have minor issues in continuity or pacing. Something that might detract from a solid story.

* * Two Stars – An “okay” read. Something I would not generally recommend to others. The writing likely has a few minor issues in continuity or pacing or perhaps something major and glaring. Something that definitely detracted from making it at least a good story.

* One Star – Something I just couldn’t finish. A story that had too many issues or problems to overlook.

Generally speaking, I won’t post anything publicly below a three star review. Some three star reviews go public and others don’t. I will follow up privately with the author (if they are willing to engage) and discuss why I feel it warrants a one or two star review in the hopes they might take the time to review the issues with the story, or if nothing else, take it as a learning experience and improve from there.

I wanted to preface that as I get the occasional message of “I never see you give out anything other than four and five star reviews.”

The truth of the matter is I haven’t POSTED them but I have given them.

Some of the counter argument I get of that “policy” is “well then how is a reader supposed to know about a bad read?”

I am not in the market to steer people away from a book with a PUBLIC bashing of it (even if it is justified). If someone asks me specifically about a title that I PRIVATELY “three stared” (or less) I will tell them why I didn’t like it.

If someone says to me “hey, what’s a good [GENRE] that you liked, THEN I point them to something I enjoyed rather than say “stay away from this”. Now if they ask me about [TWO STAR TITLE] I am likely to say “well, I really didn’t care for it and I would recommend [TITLE] instead”.

Just because I found something “two star” why should I publicly dissuade someone else from it? They might find it OK, or even like it.

So that’s just my rhyme and reason of how and why I do what it is I do.

Advertisements

The discovery of Another Sunset?

So this morning over on Twitter I have a new follower @TayeDiggs.

THE Taye Diggs.

taye

Then I remembered from a while back that @SonyPictures also followed me.

sony

How cool it would be if this is how the discovery of my book, Another Sunset, starts.

Hey – I write fiction; I’m entitled to my imagination and I am sure stranger things have happened.

Before Another Sunset – ‪FREE‬ through end of day Friday 2/27/2015

Before Another Sunset – ‪FREE‬ through end of day Friday (‪Giveaway‬ ends at midnight)

#1 ranked Kindle Short Reads > Literature & Fiction
#8 ranked in Kindle eBooks > Literature & Fiction > Literary Fiction

http://www.amazon.com/Before-Another-Sunset-Series-Book-ebook/dp/B00T11GKYE/

After midnight Saturday it goes back to ‪‎99 cents‬

Even if you’re not thinking to read it just yet, grab it now while it’s free and put it on the side for when you have the time.

number one

Does social networking work when trying to market your product?

So quickly here is my PRO argument on the subject with a 12 hour old tweet (at the time of this post). The caveat being (at least partially) “what is your product and how many people want / need it.”

Tweet one tweet two

In my next post on this subject I will show you why I personally think quick, easy, and simple is best.

New review posted for Another Sunset; rankings for Before Another Sunset climb

A new review showed up today for the main novel “Another Sunset”:

review

New numbers are also in as part of the “Before Another Sunset” campaign:

#2984 in Overall Kindle Store for free books.
#15 in Kindle Short Reads > One hour (33-43 pages) > Literature & Fiction
#46 in Literature & Fiction > Literary Fiction

new numbers

Looking forward to the remainder of the week.